Lege Artis Medicinae

[Physician attitudes concerning complementary and alternative medicine]

ZÖRGŐ Szilvia, GYŐRFFY Zsuzsa

OCTOBER 20, 2016

Lege Artis Medicinae - 2016;26(09-10)

[INTRODUCTION - A crucial challenge for XXI. century health care is the presence of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM). A marked question of professional discourse has been characterizing patient CAM use, yet the attitudes, knowledge, and opinions of physicians have received far less attention. METHODS - This qualitative study involves semi-structured interviews conducted with 45 physicians. The narratives were scrutinized by employing Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) via At­las.ti software. RESULTS - The narratives were coded ac­cording to attitudes and opinions concerning CAM, and subsequently participants were placed into 3 main groups. The first group is distinguished by a total rejection of CAM (n=11), while at the other end of the continuum, participants integrated biomedicine with CAM therapies (n=8). Those participants in between the two poles (rejection and integration) were characterized as „acceptance with reservations” and signify a heterogeneous category regarding composition and attitudes. COMMENTS - Most participants in our sample belonged to the „acceptance with reservations” category, that is, physicians who do not employ CAM in their praxis, albeit support their patients should they decide to utilize a CAM modality. Our inquiry aims to serve as a precursor to a quantitative study concerning CAM use.]

COMMENTS

0 comments

Further articles in this publication

Lege Artis Medicinae

[Processes of old age - Report from the XXXI. Congress of the Hungarian Association of Gerontology]

SZÉKÁCS Béla

Lege Artis Medicinae

[Conversation with the relatives]

ZELENA András, MONOSTORI Dóra

[In our strong opinion in hospitals the efficient conversation among staff and patient and/or relatives is important. We try to draw attention to the psychosocial aspects of pediatric intensive care and the complex and special case of relative-staff communication via the introduction of a clinical case. Various medical experts were involved in the treatment of the infant and all participants witnessed the 4 months long life and the death of the newborn. The case of the intubed patient was painful and stressful for the medical staff. With our case-report, we try to present the spectrum, which forms during the treatment of a sickly born infant and the changes of the relationship of the medical staff and relatives as well as the engrossment of their interpersonal relationship along with the center of their communication problems and solution-finding. Our paper is centered around the psychosocial aspect of the clinical case and we would like to call the attention on how the medical experts communicated with the parents of the infant. ]

Lege Artis Medicinae

[Life Practices – On the Practice of Antique Philosophy ]

TILLMANN József A.

Lege Artis Medicinae

[Many faces of thyroid hormone deficiency]

MOLNÁR Ildikó

[The timely detection of thyroid hormone deficiency is crucial to inhibit the dangerous consequences of related diseases, such as obesity, cardiovascular diseases, type 2 diabetes mellitus, breast cancer, bone wasting, menstruation disturbance, and goitrogenesis. Subclinical hypothyroidism (<10 mU/l TSH) can initiate the above mentioned symptoms and diseases, therefore its early detection and treatment is necessary. The manuscript details from a practical point of view the causes leading to thyroid hormone deficiency, their consequences and gives recommendation for starting the treatment. The increased occurrence of breast and colorectal cancers associated with thyroid hormone deficiency is explained, and the attention to concomitantly elevated prolactin levels is called. Finally, the paper gives proposals for the clinical practice, when we should think of thyroid hormone deficiency and reports on the algorithm of the treatment of subclinical hypo­thyroidism recommended by the European Thyroid Association (ETA) in 2013.]

Lege Artis Medicinae

[Crystal deposition in the background of a thyroid nodule]

BÉLY Miklós, PÉTER Ilona, SZŐKE János, GÁTI Tamás, KOLTAI Pál

[The authors present the findings of thyroid surgery in a patient treated for rheumatoid arthritis. An operation was performed due to the rapidly enlarged thyroid. In addition to the complex developmental anomaly, different crystals were found in the surgical material, which had called attention to the possibly affected mineral metabolism. Actually/Currently, the patient is not suffering from a clinically detectable metabolic disease or arthropathia induced by any crystal. The definitive crystal deposition in tissues, however, calls the physicians attention that the patient in addition to the treatment of the underlying disease should be examined in direction of a possibly developing metabolic disease, and, if necessary, an effective therapy should be used in a very early phase. ]

All articles in the issue

Related contents

Journal of Nursing Theory and Practice

[“I can’t, and won’t, do anything else.” Survey of the career orientation and career perception of BSc nursing students]

PICZIL Márta, PIKÓ Bettina

[Aim of the study: To map out the motivation that drove BSc nursing students to choose a profession in the health sector and begin their college studies. The authors considered it important to include, in the scope of the study, an assessment of the perception and prestige of the chosen vocation, as well as the level of work satisfaction. Sample and methods: The self-completion questionnaire was filled out by BSc nursing students at the Faculty of Health Sciences and Social Studies of the University of Szeged (N=208). The sample consisted of correspondence (n=136) and full-time (n=72) students, who took part in the data gathering on a voluntary basis. Results: A helpful attitude and humanistic values are what most influenced the respondents in relation to their choice of career, and their enrolment in college studies was mainly motivated by their internal drive. These attitudes, however, do not fully offset the low prestige and the negative aspects of the profession. Conclusions: The results show that there is a need for comprehensive reform in the sector, in the interest of improving the prestige of the profession and preventing career abandonment.]

Journal of Nursing Theory and Practice

[Nurse student’s attitude, knowledge and experience related to complementary medicine]

SÁRVÁRY Andrea, HAJDUNÉ DEMCSÁK Lívia, RADÓ Sándorné, SÁRVÁRY Attila

[Aim of the research: Investigating nurse students’ attitude towards complementary and alternative medicine and their knowledge of and experience with it. Research and sampling methods: 171 Hungarian nurse (57 full time and 114 part time) students participated in our cross-sectional study using a self-administered questionnaire. Results: Nurse students’ attitude towards alternative medicine is positive. The most known alternative methods were massage, herbal medicine, acupuncture, homeopathy, relaxation and meditation. The most used practices were massage, herbal medicine and homeopathy and found them efficient. Full time students used the Internet and part time students used education as information sources. Most students agreed that the integration of alternative methods into health care would be effective, and it should be taught in higher education. Conclusions: Nursing student would get reliable knowledge by integrating alternative medicine into higher education system and it takes their work more effective. ]

Clinical Neuroscience

Mental health of physicians - nationwide representative study from Hungary

GYŐRFFY Zsuzsa, GIRASEK Edmond

Background and aim - Somatic and mental health and stress factors of physicians became an issue of growing interest in both national and international researches. Our aim is to give an overviewing analysis of Hungarian physicians’ mental health state. Methods - Representative, cross-sectional, quantitative survey on a representative sample of Hungarian physicians (n=4784). The control group was formed by the population group of a national survey conducted by “Hungarostudy 2013” (n=2000). Results - Suicidal thoughts (18.8% vs. 9.6%, p<0.001), the scores of Somatic Symptom Scale (PHQ-10, 20.4% vs. 13.6%, p<0.001) were significantly higher among physicians. The suicidal attempts (1.9% vs. 3.5%, p=0.053) and BDI depression scores (7.9% vs. 29.5%, p<0.001) were significantly higher in the control group. High Perceived Stress Scale (PPS) scores occurred in 43.3% of the physicians sample, and 43.4% of them had high scores in the Athenian Insomnia Scale (AIS). The young (<35) female physicians showed significantly higher rates of suicidal thoughts, higher scores of PHQ and PPS. In the young female cohort, the AIS scores were significantly higher than of the other physicians. Conclusions - Mental health of physicians (sleep disorders, suicidal thoughts and psychosomatic symptoms) showed poorer results than the population data. BDI scores and the rate of suicidal attempts showed favourable trends. The next step in the physicians’ mental health researches is to investigate the most decisive risk factors, and to work out the prevention tools.

Lege Artis Medicinae

[Legal status and regulation of complementary and alternative medicine in Europe]

HEGYI Gabriella, VINJAR Fønnebø, TORKEL Falkenberg, HÖK Johanna, SOLVEIG Wiesener

[OBJECTIVE - This study aims to review the current legal status of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) in the 27 member states and 12 associated states of the European Union (EU). METHODS - We contacted national Ministries of Health and educational institutions of all participating countries, international, local and regional CAM associations and members of the EU project CAMbrella. Literature search was performed in governmental, scientific and popular science websites as well as the web sites/databases of health ministries and EU and Hungarian law documents. RESULTS - All 39 nations have different legislative frameworks and different regulations of CAM. CAM activities are regulated by health legislation in 17 member states, 11 of which have created a specific CAM law, and 6 of which include sections related to CAM in their general health laws. Some countries only regulate several CAM treatments. Preparations, agents and herbal products used in CAM are subject to similar authorization requirements in all countries, comparably to other medicinal products. One exception is the requirement for documentation of efficacy studies. The Directives, Regulations and Resolutions of the EU will affect the conditions that might influence CAM treatment(s) in Europe. CONCLUSION - We experienced an extraordinary diversity in EU countries with regard to the regulation and practice of CAM, but did not find differences in the regulation of herbal products and medicines used in CAM. This motivates patients, practitioners as well as researchers when crossing the borders of European countries. In the current legislative environment we think that harmonisation of law is possible within the EU: individual states within culturally similar regions should harmonise their CAM legislation and regulation. This would probably safeguard against inadequately justified, over- or underregulated practice at national levels. In Hungary, modifications of the decree regulating on CAM are currently being prepared following professional recommendations. This outdated decree needs to be reconsidered, as 17 years of practice have shown which practices are worthy to be maintainted, taught and applied within the healthcare system and which should be omitted.]

Lege Artis Medicinae

[MC world - a board game of medical communication]

KOLLÁR János

[In 2015 in the Institute of Behavioral Sciences of Semmelweis University a board game named MC World (Medical Communi­ca­tion World) was designed to further student learning in the field of medical communication by gamifying the learning material. 29 Hungarian and 28 foreign students were participating in a study where the acceptance of the game and its attitude change effect regarding medical communication were tested. The participants evaluated statements in connection with the game on a 5 point Likert-type scale. The survey responses suggest that both the Hungarian and the foreign medical students considered the application of the game in education as a practical and successful initiation. It draws the attention to better utilization of gamification as an educational facilitator and as a positive opinion forming opportunity.]