Lege Artis Medicinae

[Legal status and regulation of complementary and alternative medicine in Europe]

HEGYI Gabriella, VINJAR Fønnebø, TORKEL Falkenberg, HÖK Johanna, SOLVEIG Wiesener

AUGUST 20, 2013

Lege Artis Medicinae - 2013;23(07-08)

[OBJECTIVE - This study aims to review the current legal status of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) in the 27 member states and 12 associated states of the European Union (EU). METHODS - We contacted national Ministries of Health and educational institutions of all participating countries, international, local and regional CAM associations and members of the EU project CAMbrella. Literature search was performed in governmental, scientific and popular science websites as well as the web sites/databases of health ministries and EU and Hungarian law documents. RESULTS - All 39 nations have different legislative frameworks and different regulations of CAM. CAM activities are regulated by health legislation in 17 member states, 11 of which have created a specific CAM law, and 6 of which include sections related to CAM in their general health laws. Some countries only regulate several CAM treatments. Preparations, agents and herbal products used in CAM are subject to similar authorization requirements in all countries, comparably to other medicinal products. One exception is the requirement for documentation of efficacy studies. The Directives, Regulations and Resolutions of the EU will affect the conditions that might influence CAM treatment(s) in Europe. CONCLUSION - We experienced an extraordinary diversity in EU countries with regard to the regulation and practice of CAM, but did not find differences in the regulation of herbal products and medicines used in CAM. This motivates patients, practitioners as well as researchers when crossing the borders of European countries. In the current legislative environment we think that harmonisation of law is possible within the EU: individual states within culturally similar regions should harmonise their CAM legislation and regulation. This would probably safeguard against inadequately justified, over- or underregulated practice at national levels. In Hungary, modifications of the decree regulating on CAM are currently being prepared following professional recommendations. This outdated decree needs to be reconsidered, as 17 years of practice have shown which practices are worthy to be maintainted, taught and applied within the healthcare system and which should be omitted.]

COMMENTS

0 comments

Further articles in this publication

Lege Artis Medicinae

[A Man of Spirit – Remembering Béla Buda]

KAPÓCS Gábor

Lege Artis Medicinae

[The Face of Impressionism]

NAGY Zsuzsanna

Lege Artis Medicinae

[The Lone Star]

CSEPELI György

Lege Artis Medicinae

[The Remedy for Physicians – About Béla Buda]

Lege Artis Medicinae

[Only the Body ]

SZUMMER Csaba

All articles in the issue

Related contents

Lege Artis Medicinae

[MEDICINAL HERBS IN THE TREATMENT OF LIVER DISEASES]

SCHULLER János

[Today, alternative medicine is increasingly popular among patients. Patients with liver diseases surprisingly often use complementary treatment, mainly medicinal herbs, with or without the knowledge of their physician. This is one of the reasons why doctors may not ignore alternative medicine. Another reason is that twenty to thirty percent of medicaments now used in conventional therapy were originally produced from herbs. This means that some of the herbal medicines now applied in alternative therapy may become a conventional drug in the future. This paper reviews publications of evidencebased medicine on herbal medicines most often used in the treatment of liver diseases, including silymarin, glycyrrhizin, phyllantus amarus, CH- 100, LIV.52, sho-saiko-to, bin-gan, compund 861 and oxymatrine. It is important for physicians to be also knowledgeable about potentially hepatotoxic medicinal herbs.]

Lege Artis Medicinae

[Physician attitudes concerning complementary and alternative medicine]

ZÖRGŐ Szilvia, GYŐRFFY Zsuzsa

[INTRODUCTION - A crucial challenge for XXI. century health care is the presence of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM). A marked question of professional discourse has been characterizing patient CAM use, yet the attitudes, knowledge, and opinions of physicians have received far less attention. METHODS - This qualitative study involves semi-structured interviews conducted with 45 physicians. The narratives were scrutinized by employing Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) via At­las.ti software. RESULTS - The narratives were coded ac­cording to attitudes and opinions concerning CAM, and subsequently participants were placed into 3 main groups. The first group is distinguished by a total rejection of CAM (n=11), while at the other end of the continuum, participants integrated biomedicine with CAM therapies (n=8). Those participants in between the two poles (rejection and integration) were characterized as „acceptance with reservations” and signify a heterogeneous category regarding composition and attitudes. COMMENTS - Most participants in our sample belonged to the „acceptance with reservations” category, that is, physicians who do not employ CAM in their praxis, albeit support their patients should they decide to utilize a CAM modality. Our inquiry aims to serve as a precursor to a quantitative study concerning CAM use.]

Clinical Neuroscience

Late simultaneous carcinomatous meningitis, temporal bone infiltrating macro-metastasis and disseminated multi-organ micro-metastases presenting with mono-symptomatic vertigo – a clinico-pathological case reporT

JARABIN András János, KLIVÉNYI Péter, TISZLAVICZ László, MOLNÁR Anna Fiona, GION Katalin, FÖLDESI Imre, KISS Geza Jozsef, ROVÓ László, BELLA Zsolt

Although vertigo is one of the most common complaints, intracranial malignant tumors rarely cause sudden asymmetry between the tone of the vestibular peripheries masquerading as a peripheral-like disorder. Here we report a case of simultaneous temporal bone infiltrating macro-metastasis and disseminated multi-organ micro-metastases presenting as acute unilateral vestibular syndrome, due to the reawakening of a primary gastric signet ring cell carcinoma. Purpose – Our objective was to identify those pathophysiological steps that may explain the complex process of tumor reawakening, dissemination. The possible causes of vestibular asymmetry were also traced. A 56-year-old male patient’s interdisciplinary medical data had been retrospectively analyzed. Original clinical and pathological results have been collected and thoroughly reevaluated, then new histological staining and immunohistochemistry methods have been added to the diagnostic pool. During the autopsy the cerebrum and cerebellum was edematous. The apex of the left petrous bone was infiltrated and destructed by a tumor mass of 2x2 cm in size. Histological reexamination of the original gastric resection specimen slides revealed focal submucosal tumorous infiltration with a vascular invasion. By immunohistochemistry mainly single infiltrating tumor cells were observed with Cytokeratin 7 and Vimentin positivity and partial loss of E-cadherin staining. The subsequent histological examination of necropsy tissue specimens confirmed the disseminated, multi-organ microscopic tumorous invasion. Discussion – It has been recently reported that the expression of Vimentin and the loss of E-cadherin is significantly associated with advanced stage, lymph node metastasis, vascular and neural invasion and undifferentiated type with p<0.05 significance. As our patient was middle aged and had no immune-deficiency, the promoting factor of the reawakening of the primary GC malignant disease after a 9-year-long period of dormancy remained undiscovered. The organ-specific tropism explained by the “seed and soil” theory was unexpected, due to rare occurrence of gastric cancer to metastasize in the meninges given that only a minority of these cells would be capable of crossing the blood brain barrier. Patients with past malignancies and new onset of neurological symptoms should alert the physician to central nervous system involvement, and the appropriate, targeted diagnostic and therapeutic work-up should be established immediately. Targeted staining with specific antibodies is recommended. Recent studies on cell lines indicate that metformin strongly inhibits epithelial-mesenchymal transition of gastric cancer cells. Therefore, further studies need to be performed on cases positive for epithelial-mesenchymal transition.